Our 5th grade recently spent some time in the library exploring places in texts where the reader must make an inference in order to know the full story. This is a standard that our 5th graders work on in the first quarter.
ELAGSE5RL1: Quotes accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text.
To prepare for this lesson, I spent some time reading several picture books as well as exploring what other educators have done with inferences. This post by Pernille Ripp was especially helpful. Anytime we work on language arts standards, I want a good portion of our time to be spent actually reading rather than just practicing a specific skill. With picture book month approaching, I thought this experience would be a good time to reiterate with our older readers that picture books are for all readers and to give them time to read at least 2-3 books during our time together.
Here are the books I decided to pull for this experience:
- The Skunk by Mac Barnett
- We Found a Hat by Jon Klassen
- Shhh! We Have a Plan by Chris Haughton
- Mr. Peabody’s Apples by Madonna
- The Rough Patch by Brian Lies
- Julian Is a Mermaid by Jessica Love
- Rules of Summer by Shaun Tan
- Voices in the Park by Anthony Browne
- The Other Side by Jacqueline Woodson
- After the Fall by Dan Santat
- Duck! Rabbit! by Amy Krouse Rosenthal
- My Lucky Day by Keiko Kasza
- Boats for Papa by Jessixa Bagley
- Unspoken by Henry Cole
For each book, I made a folder with instructions and a guiding question. Inside the folder, I placed some blank post-it notes.
As students entered the library, we began our time on the carpet. I launched right in to talking about a picture book author, Bethan Woollvin. I let students know about her subversive, fractured fairy tales and also that she leaves some of her story to the reader to figure out. In each class, there was usually a handful of students who mentioned that this was an inference. If they didn’t then, we talked about how we would need to make inferences when we read her stories.
I read aloud Little Red. We paused a few places to talk about inferences we must make as the reader:
- When the wolf makes a plan
- When the wolf climbs into Grandma’s bed looking completely ridiculous
- When Little Red makes a plan
- When Little Red is wearing a wolf costume at the end of the book
This whole read aloud experience was setting students up for their own task. With a partner, students chose one of the picture books I had pulled. Their goal was to enjoy the book together. While they were reading, they were invited to think about places in the text and illustrations where the author/illustrator left the story up to the reader to figure out. Any inferences could be written onto a post-it note to add to the folder for future readers to read and consider. As more students read each book, more post-it notes appeared in the folders and readers could compare their own thoughts to those of others.
The teacher and I were able to sit with pairs of students and listen to their reading. Sometimes we read aloud with them as well and became a natural part of the conversation on inferences. What I loved the most was looking around and seeing so many 5th grade readers engaged with a text and having a genuinely good time reading them. The inference part was low key enough that the enjoyment of the book was the more central part of their time.
We closed our time by having any pairs of students who loved a book do a short book talk for others and highlight where that book could be found in the library. My hope was that this would be a spark to our picture book month challenge where students are encouraged to read a picture book from each genre section of the library.